It is a strange and trying time for all of us in the midst of the COVID-19 pandemic. We certainly understand times are tough for you, as it is for us. We have been proud to bring School Band & Orchestra for free for more than two decades and we will continue to provide you with free subscriptions during the pandemic. However, we would like your consideration in these difficult times to help support our efforts here at School Band & Orchestra to keep our information flowing and to provide you with a continuous stream of current and vital information when you need it the most.
It is with the utmost sincerity we ask you to consider supporting our efforts here with a small donation which will allow our staff the ability to keep these interesting stories about your chosen career coming to you in a consistent and timely basis. Your consideration is greatly appreciated. We at School Band & Orchestra wish nothing but the best for you, your school, your family and co-workers. We hope you continue to remain healthy during this most strenuous of times.
By Tom Merrill
We lived in the Boulder, Colorado, area for nearly 15 years. If you’ve ever been there, you know that it is a bit of an eclectic place. Legally now.
One of our favorite things to do was to go downtown to the Pearl Street Mall, an outdoor open air plaza that was usually filled with street performers demonstrating a wide variety of talents. Poets, singers, and activists. Sometimes musicians with guitars or other instruments, always with a case open for spare change. The one that always drew a crowd was “the ZIP Code Guy.” This was a person who could tell you the city and state where you lived if you told him your ZIP code. Freaky, yet entertaining.
I often felt badly for the truly talented ones–and there were several. Here they were, pouring heart and soul and emotion into their performance art…surrounded by shoppers hustling about, the occasional siren screaming by, small children noisily running past them, and any number of other distractions that merely made them part of the scenery.
As the economy slowed in 2008, one of the natural trends in performance travel was to work to keep costs managed to allow as many students to participate as possible. It was a wise move and likely helped preserve travel traditions in countless music departments. One of the ways this was done was to find public locations where groups could perform for low to no cost, thus being able to maintain the premise of a music tour and satisfy administrations and school boards by having musical content…while saving money in the process.
The unfortunate trade-off was in the quality of the performance setting, and the acceptance of “good enough” for the cost. These talented musicians became simply part of the scenery, and this became a new normal for music tours.
As the economy improves, perhaps now is the time to reconsider this approach. And while it will obviously appear self-serving to hear this coming from a festival organization…in the bigger picture should consideration be given to the impression that use of these free locations makes regarding the value placed on music education? Is it truly “good enough” for our young musicians?
Compared to a free performance at an open public venue, a performance event—whether a competition or a collaborative effort—offers much more:
There is deeper educational and musical value added to your tour:
Quality over Quantity. A meaningful music tour should include setting and achieving goals that lead to growth for the individual musician and the program as a whole, rather than a “checklist” of activities. If a performance is to be a part of your music tour plans, you want it to be an opportunity that enhances the education and growth of your students and your program.
Ultimately a successful music tour is about balance–putting equal weight on the musical aspects and the fun activities. Making certain that the music portion is worthwhile and rewarding makes it easier to justify the truly long-term value of the experience.
Tom Merrill is the executive director of Festivals of Music. Prior to festival management, he was a high school band director and a student travel planner.